In financial reporting and valuation, particularly in business combinations, understanding the relationships and applications of the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC), Weighted Average Return on Assets (WARA), and Internal Rate of Return (IRR) is essential. This article delves into these financial metrics and their roles in Purchase Price Allocations (PPA), with a focus on their relevance to valuation practices in Singapore.

Financial reporting standards such as Singapore Financial Reporting Standard (SFRS) 103 mandate that assets and liabilities acquired in a business combination be measured at their fair values based on market participant assumptions, excluding buyer-specific synergies. Consequently, the projected cash flows or income from the acquired business and intangible assets must reflect these assumptions. Understanding and reconciling WACC, WARA, and IRR is essential for assessing the financial implications of an acquisition.

WACC represents the average rate of return a company is anticipated to provide to its security holders for financing its assets. In business combinations, WACC serves as the benchmark discount rate for evaluating the future cash flows generated by the acquired assets, reflecting the cost of equity and debt weighted by their respective use in the company’s capital structure.

Accurately determining the WACC in a PPA ensures that the valuation reflects the cost of capital and associated risks. For instance, if the WACC is understated, the present value of future cash flows will be overstated, potentially leading to an overestimation of the value of the acquired intangible assets.

Internal Rate of Return (IRR) is a tool used to assess the profitability of an investment by equating the present value of future cash flows to the initial investment cost. In PPAs, the IRR is calculated by aligning the acquisition’s purchase consideration and assumed debt obligations with the market value of the acquiree’s invested capital.

The alignment between IRR and WACC is critical. Discrepancies between the two may indicate issues in the projected financial information (PFI) or the acquisition price. The relationship can be summarized as follows:

Weighted Average Return on Assets (WARA)

WARA is a corroborative tool used in PPAs to evaluate the reasonableness of the selected rates of return on individual assets and the proportion of debt/equity used to finance their acquisition. WARA is the weighted sum of the required rates of return for various asset categories, including property, plant, and equipment (PPE), working capital, cash and cash equivalents, other assets, and intangible assets.

Conceptually, the weighted average return of these assets should approximate the organization’s cost of capital. A WARA that aligns with the WACC reflects the reasonableness of the selected rates of return on individual assets and the weights assigned to them. If WARA deviates significantly from WACC, it may indicate that the returns expected on the assets are not commensurate with their risks or that the asset values are misaligned with their fair values.

Goodwill: Understanding and Managing its Implications

Goodwill is recorded when the acquisition cost surpasses the fair value of the identifiable net assets. It often includes buyer-specific synergies and intangible assets that are not separately identifiable. While goodwill is an intangible asset with indefinite life, its valuation and expected return require careful consideration.

In practice, goodwill is often scrutinized to ensure that it reflects the true value of the synergies and intangible benefits expected from the acquisition. Excessive goodwill relative to industry norms may indicate overpayment or overly conservative financial projections. Valuers need to assess whether the goodwill’s return aligns with the overall business’s risk profile or if a premium should be applied to account for its indefinite life and speculative nature.

Practical Considerations for Valuers and Auditors

For valuation practitioners and auditors, ensuring that the weightage of debt and equity attributed to each asset is consistent with the overall debt and equity proportions used in the WACC calculation is critical. This consistency ensures the credibility and accuracy of the PPA.

Auditors play an important role in assessing the reasonableness of fair value measurements and validating the underlying assumptions used in PPAs through IRR, WARA, and WACC analyses. These analyses help identify potential discrepancies and ensure that the financial information reflects market participant assumptions accurately.

Share via